Health & Dental “Self-Insure vs. Plan” Estimator
Work out whether a private retiree health and dental plan earns its premium, or whether paying your own drug, dental and vision bills costs less once the medical expense credit and your provincial drug safety net are counted.
Premiums + deductibles vs out-of-pocket · Medical expense credit · Drug program relief
Your coverage choices
Drug safety net: Ontario Trillium Drug Program. Deductible of roughly 4% of household net income, then a small per-prescription co-payment. The two percentage fields below are pre-filled from this program and can be edited.
Used for the credit threshold and the drug program deductible. Line 23600 of your return.
Full pharmacy cost before any plan or public program.
The retiree health and dental quote you are considering, per person.
The most the plan pays for dental and vision in a year. Costs above it are yours.
Estimated net annual cost
Private plan + out-of-pocket
$3,455
About $288 a month
Self-insure, pay out-of-pocket
$2,967
About $247 a month
Self-insuring costs about $488 less a year, or $41 a month, after the public drug program and the medical expense credit.
Total health spending before any coverage: $3,260 a year ($2,400 drugs, $860 dental and vision).
Where the money goes
| Cost | Private plan | Self-insure |
|---|---|---|
| Premiums | $2,640 | $0 |
| Drugs you pay for | $539 | $2,400 |
| Dental and vision you pay for | $276 | $860 |
| Ontario Trillium Drug Program relief | $0 | $0 |
| Medical expense credit (0.2% of costs above $1,800) | $0 | -$293 |
| Net annual cost | $3,455 | $2,967 |
The plan pays $2,445 of your $3,260 in eligible costs, including $1,861 for drugs and $584 for dental and vision after the $100 deductible.
Credits and drug programs
Medical expense tax credit
Premiums you pay for private health coverage do not qualify. Only your out-of-pocket drugs, dental and vision costs do — the deduction is the amount above the lesser of 3% of net income or $2,900.
Self-insuring: $293 of credit. With a plan: $0. The credit is non-refundable, so it only helps if you owe tax.
Ontario Trillium Drug Program
Deductible of roughly 4% of household net income, then a small per-prescription co-payment.
Modelled deductible: $2,400 (4% of net income), then a 0% share. Estimated relief: $0 if you self-insure, $0 with the plan.
Check the current program rulesThe credit combines the 15% federal credit with a -14.8% provincial credit at that province’s lowest rate. Actual provincial credits vary, and the credit is worth nothing if you have no tax payable.
How this estimate is built
Both routes are priced on the same year of spending. With a plan, you pay twelve premiums, the deductible, and your share of drugs and dental/vision up to the annual maximum. Self-insuring, you pay the full pharmacy, dental and vision bill. The cheaper route is the one with the lower total once the public drug program and the medical expense credit are applied.
The deductible is applied to your total eligible spending, and the remainder is split between drugs and dental/vision in proportion to what you spend. Drug coverage is applied first; dental and vision coverage is capped at the annual maximum you enter. That cap is where many retiree plans disappoint: a single crown or bridge can exhaust a year of coverage.
The medical expense credit uses the lesser of 3% of net income or the indexed federal threshold. Private health insurance premiums are not eligible medical expenses for this credit. The credit is also non-refundable, so it only reduces tax you would otherwise owe, and it can be claimed by whichever spouse has the higher marginal rate.
Provincial drug safety nets are estimated from an income-based deductible and co-payment that you can edit. Real programs use household income definitions, quarterly deductibles, per-prescription co-payments, special drug categories and prior-authorization rules, and they change. Treat the deductible and co-pay percentages as starting assumptions and confirm them with the program. The tool applies the public program to whatever drug cost the private plan leaves you with.
What is not modelled: waiting periods and pre-existing condition exclusions, annual or lifetime plan maximums on drugs, paramedical services such as physiotherapy and massage, out-of-country emergency coverage, hospital semi-private rooms, the tax treatment of any employer retiree benefit subsidy, the Québec premium and abatement, and the risk that a health event makes private coverage priceless or unattainable later. Insurance is also about protecting against the large, unplanned cost rather than the routine one, and those tail risks are what this annual comparison cannot show.
Educational estimate only, not insurance, tax or financial advice. Program rules change; confirm details before you cancel or buy coverage. Read the disclaimer.
